Mindanao Daily

Election Result for Maguindanao – President

PRESIDENT of PHILIPPINES

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
AQUINO, Benigno Simeon III C. LIBERAL PARTY 163377 41.18%
VILLAR, Manuel Jr B. NACIONALISTA PARTY 125400 31.61%
ESTRADA EJERCITO, Joseph M. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 52020 13.11%
TEODORO, Gilberto Jr. C. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 47082 11.87%
VILLANUEVA, Eduardo C. BANGON PILIPINAS 4686 1.18%
GORDON, Richard J. BAGUMBAYAN-VNP 1832 0.46%
ACOSTA, Vetellano S. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 1441 0.36%
MADRIGAL, Jamby A. INDEPENDENT 444 0.11%
PERLAS, Jesus Nicanor P. INDEPENDENT 297 0.07%
DE LOS REYES, John Carlos G. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 183 0.05%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 439520
Published by: www.electionresults.comelec.gov.ph

Election Result for Maguindanao – Vice President

VICE-PRESIDENT of PHILIPPINES

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
BINAY, Jejomar C. PARTIDO DEMOKRATIKO PILIPINO LAKAS NG BAYAN 181286 47.57%
LEGARDA, Loren B. NATIONALIST PEOPLES COALITION 137752 36.15%
ROXAS, Manuel A. LIBERAL PARTY 45463 11.93%
MANZANO, Eduardo B. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 11081 2.91%
FERNANDO, Bayani F. BAGUMBAYAN-VNP 3447 0.90%
YASAY, Perfecto R. BANGON PILIPINAS 1274 0.33%
CHIPECO, Dominador Jr F. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 424 0.11%
SONZA, Jose Y. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 373 0.10%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 439520

Published by: www.electionresults.comelec.gov.ph

Election Result for Maguindanao – Partylist

PARTY LIST of PHILIPPINES

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
FILIPINO MUSLIM ORGANIZATION FILIPINO MUSLIM ORGANIZATION 57048 16.46%
ADHIKAIN NG MGA DAKILANG ANAK MAHARLIKA ADHIKAIN NG MGA DAKILANG ANAK MAHARLIKA 38315 11.06%
AKSYON MAGSASAKA PARTIDO TINIG NG MASA AKSYON MAGSASAKA PARTIDO TINIG NG MASA 36882 10.64%
ACTION FOR DEMOCRACY AND DEVELOPMENT FOR- THE TRIBAL PEOPLE ACTION FOR DEMOCRACY AND DEVELOPMENT FOR- THE TRIBAL PEOPLE 20389 5.88%
AKSYON NG MAMAMAYANG NAGKAKAISA AKSYON NG MAMAMAYANG NAGKAKAISA 15494 4.47%
AKBAYAN! CITIZEN'S ACTION PARTY AKBAYAN! CITIZEN’S ACTION PARTY 15043 4.34%
ANAK MINDANAO ANAK MINDANAO 12344 3.56%
COCONUT FARMERS ASSOCIATION OF LINAMON, LANAO DEL NORTE, INC. COCONUT FARMERS ASSOCIATION OF LINAMON, LANAO DEL NORTE, INC. 10946 3.16%
BIYAHENG PINOY LABOR ASSOCIATION, INC. BIYAHENG PINOY LABOR ASSOCIATION, INC. 10403 3.00%
ACTION LEAGUE OF INDIGENOUS MASSES ACTION LEAGUE OF INDIGENOUS MASSES 10112 2.92%
AGAPAY NG INDIGENOUS PEOPLES RIGHTS ALLIANCE, INC. AGAPAY NG INDIGENOUS PEOPLES RIGHTS ALLIANCE, INC. 10001 2.89%
YOU AGAINST CORRUPTION AND POVERTY YOU AGAINST CORRUPTION AND POVERTY 8170 2.36%
ONE ADVOCACY FOR HEALTH, PROGRESS AND OPPORTUNITY ONE ADVOCACY FOR HEALTH, PROGRESS AND OPPORTUNITY 5214 1.50%
1-UNITED TRANSPORT KOALISYON 1-UNITED TRANSPORT KOALISYON 4994 1.44%
A BLESSED FEDERATION OF FARMERS AND FISHERMEN INTERNATIONAL, INC. A BLESSED FEDERATION OF FARMERS AND FISHERMEN INTERNATIONAL, INC. 4501 1.30%
COALITION OF ASSOCIATIONS OF SENIOR CITIZENS IN THE PHILIPPINES, INC. COALITION OF ASSOCIATIONS OF SENIOR CITIZENS IN THE PHILIPPINES, INC. 4251 1.23%
YES WE CAN, INC. YES WE CAN, INC. 4208 1.21%
GABRIELA WOMENS PARTY GABRIELA WOMENS PARTY 3562 1.03%
ABANTE KATUTUBO , INC. ABANTE KATUTUBO , INC. 3428 0.99%
1ST CONSUMERS ALLIANCE FOR RURAL ENERGY 1ST CONSUMERS ALLIANCE FOR RURAL ENERGY 2875 0.83%
ADVOCACY FOR TEACHER EMPOWERMENT THROUGH ACTION COOPERATION AND HARMONY TOWARDS EDUCATIONAL REFORMS ADVOCACY FOR TEACHER EMPOWERMENT THROUGH ACTION COOPERATION AND HARMONY TOWARDS EDUCATIONAL REFORMS 2867 0.83%
VENDORS AND TRADERS ALLIANCE OF PHILIPPINES PARTY VENDORS AND TRADERS ALLIANCE OF PHILIPPINES PARTY 2619 0.76%
CITIZENS' BATTLE AGAINST CORRUPTION CITIZENS’ BATTLE AGAINST CORRUPTION 2132 0.62%
ANG LABAN NG INDIGONG FILIPINO ANG LABAN NG INDIGONG FILIPINO 1936 0.56%
ACT TEACHERS ACT TEACHERS 1893 0.55%
PILIPINO ASSOCIATION FOR COUNTRY – URBAN-POOR YOUTH ADVANCEMENT AND WELFARE PILIPINO ASSOCIATION FOR COUNTRY – URBAN-POOR YOUTH ADVANCEMENT AND WELFARE 1814 0.52%
AANGAT TAYO AANGAT TAYO 1609 0.46%
KASOSYO PRODUCER-CONSUMER EXCHANGE ASSOCIATION, INC. KASOSYO PRODUCER-CONSUMER EXCHANGE ASSOCIATION, INC. 1585 0.46%
BAYAN MUNA BAYAN MUNA 1574 0.45%
COOPERATIVE NATCCO NETWORK PARTY COOPERATIVE NATCCO NETWORK PARTY 1415 0.41%
ABANTE TRIBUNG MAKABANSA ABANTE TRIBUNG MAKABANSA 1369 0.40%
ITENERANT VENDORS ALLIANCE OF THE PHILIPPINES ITENERANT VENDORS ALLIANCE OF THE PHILIPPINES 1291 0.37%
TRADE UNION CONGRESS PARTY TRADE UNION CONGRESS PARTY 1285 0.37%
KABATAAN PARTYLIST KABATAAN PARTYLIST 1273 0.37%
UNA ANG PAMILYA FORMERLY ALLIANCE OF NEO-CONSERVATIVES UNA ANG PAMILYA FORMERLY ALLIANCE OF NEO-CONSERVATIVES 1239 0.36%
BIYAYANG BUKID BIYAYANG BUKID 1121 0.32%
ACTION FOR DYNAMIC DEVELOPMENT, INC. ACTION FOR DYNAMIC DEVELOPMENT, INC. 1075 0.31%
ANG MATA'Y ALAGAAN ANG MATA’Y ALAGAAN 1034 0.30%
ANG PARTIDO DEMOKRATIKO RURAL ANG PARTIDO DEMOKRATIKO RURAL 1028 0.30%
ALYANSA NG MGA GRUPONG HALIGI NG AGHAM AT TEKNOLOHIYA PARA SA MAMAMAYAN, INC. ALYANSA NG MGA GRUPONG HALIGI NG AGHAM AT TEKNOLOHIYA PARA SA MAMAMAYAN, INC. 975 0.28%
AKO BICOL POLITICAL PARTY AKO BICOL POLITICAL PARTY 938 0.27%
ASSOCIATION FOR RIGHTEOUSNESS ADVOCAY IN LEADERSHIP ASSOCIATION FOR RIGHTEOUSNESS ADVOCAY IN LEADERSHIP 931 0.27%
VETERANS FREEDOM PARTY VETERANS FREEDOM PARTY 862 0.25%
PUWERSA NG BAYANING ATLETA PUWERSA NG BAYANING ATLETA 843 0.24%
ASSOCIATION OF LABORERS AND EMPLOYEES ASSOCIATION OF LABORERS AND EMPLOYEES 836 0.24%
1-AKO BABAENG ASTIG AASENSO 1-AKO BABAENG ASTIG AASENSO 798 0.23%
ANGAT ATING KABUHAYAN PILIPINAS, INC. ANGAT ATING KABUHAYAN PILIPINAS, INC. 737 0.21%
ALYANSANG BAYANIHAN NG MGA MAGSASAKA, MANGGAGAWANG-BUKID AT MANGINGISDA ALYANSANG BAYANIHAN NG MGA MAGSASAKA, MANGGAGAWANG-BUKID AT MANGINGISDA 713 0.21%
1-AANI 1-AANI 710 0.20%
A CONVERGENCE FOR MINDANAO AGENDA, INC. A CONVERGENCE FOR MINDANAO AGENDA, INC. 709 0.20%
ALLIANCE OF ADVOCATES IN MINING ADVANCEMENT FOR NATIONAL PROGRESS ALLIANCE OF ADVOCATES IN MINING ADVANCEMENT FOR NATIONAL PROGRESS 696 0.20%
AKBAY PINOY OFW-NATIONAL, INC. AKBAY PINOY OFW-NATIONAL, INC. 683 0.20%
ANG ASOSASYON SANG MANGUNGUMA NGA BISAYA-OWA MANGUNGUMA, INC. ANG ASOSASYON SANG MANGUNGUMA NGA BISAYA-OWA MANGUNGUMA, INC. 656 0.19%
ALYANSA LUMAD, INC. ALYANSA LUMAD, INC. 649 0.19%
ASSOCIATION OF PHILIPPINE ELECTRIC COOPERATIVES ASSOCIATION OF PHILIPPINE ELECTRIC COOPERATIVES 610 0.18%
FREE WORKERS FREE WORKERS 586 0.17%
ALYANSA NG MAMAMAYANG NAGHIHIRAP ALYANSA NG MAMAMAYANG NAGHIHIRAP 559 0.16%
DEMOCRATIC INDEPENDENT WORKERS' ASSOCIATION, INC. DEMOCRATIC INDEPENDENT WORKERS’ ASSOCIATION, INC. 548 0.16%
ABANTE MINDANAO, INC. ABANTE MINDANAO, INC. 543 0.16%
ALLIANCE OF PEOPLE'S ORGANIZATIONS ALLIANCE OF PEOPLE’S ORGANIZATIONS 543 0.16%
BARANGAY NATIN BARANGAY NATIN 526 0.15%
ALLIANCE FOR RURAL CONCERNS ALLIANCE FOR RURAL CONCERNS 520 0.15%
KALAHI SECTORAL PARTY KALAHI SECTORAL PARTY 518 0.15%
KATIPUNAN NG MGA ANAK NG BAYAN ALL FILIPINO DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT KATIPUNAN NG MGA ANAK NG BAYAN ALL FILIPINO DEMOCRATIC MOVEMENT 508 0.15%
BUHAY HAYAAN YUMABONG BUHAY HAYAAN YUMABONG 501 0.14%
ANG KALUSUGAN PARA SA PINOY, INC. ANG KALUSUGAN PARA SA PINOY, INC. 472 0.14%
AGRARIAN DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION AGRARIAN DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION 469 0.14%
AGBIAG! TIMPUYOG ILOCANO, INC. AGBIAG! TIMPUYOG ILOCANO, INC. 461 0.13%
1GUARDIANS NATIONALIST OF THE PHILIPPINES, INC. 1GUARDIANS NATIONALIST OF THE PHILIPPINES, INC. 445 0.13%
ANAKPAWIS ANAKPAWIS 441 0.13%
ALLIANCE FOR NATIONALISM AND DEMOCRACY ALLIANCE FOR NATIONALISM AND DEMOCRACY 416 0.12%
WOMENPOWER, INC. WOMENPOWER, INC. 399 0.12%
ANG ASSOSIASYON NG MGA TRABAHADOR AT PAHINANTE ANG ASSOSIASYON NG MGA TRABAHADOR AT PAHINANTE 390 0.11%
AGILA NG KATUTUBONG PILIPINO, INC. AGILA NG KATUTUBONG PILIPINO, INC. 381 0.11%
ALYANSA NG OFW PARTY ALYANSA NG OFW PARTY 377 0.11%
ANG LADLAD LBGT PARTY ANG LADLAD LBGT PARTY 370 0.11%
ALLIANCE FOR BARANGAY CONCERNS PARTY ALLIANCE FOR BARANGAY CONCERNS PARTY 368 0.11%
ALLIANCE FRO PHILIPPINES SECURITY GUARDS COOPERATIVE ALLIANCE FRO PHILIPPINES SECURITY GUARDS COOPERATIVE 362 0.10%
AKAP BATA, INC. AKAP BATA, INC. 360 0.10%
KATRIBU INDIGENOUS PEOPLE'S SECTORAL PARTY KATRIBU INDIGENOUS PEOPLE’S SECTORAL PARTY 359 0.10%
FIRM 24-K ASSOCIATION, INC. FIRM 24-K ASSOCIATION, INC. 357 0.10%
ALLIANCE OF NATIONAL URBAN POOR ORGANIZATIONS ASSEMBLY, INC. ALLIANCE OF NATIONAL URBAN POOR ORGANIZATIONS ASSEMBLY, INC. 351 0.10%
1-AANGAT KA PILIPINO 1-AANGAT KA PILIPINO 350 0.10%
BAGONG BAYAN NA NAGTATAGUYOD NG DEMOKRATIKONG IDEOLOHIYA AT LAYUNIN BAGONG BAYAN NA NAGTATAGUYOD NG DEMOKRATIKONG IDEOLOHIYA AT LAYUNIN 341 0.10%
THE TRUE MARCOS LOYALIST (FOR GOD COUNTRY and PEOPLE) ASSOCIATION OF THE PHIL., INC. THE TRUE MARCOS LOYALIST (FOR GOD COUNTRY and PEOPLE) ASSOCIATION OF THE PHIL., INC. 334 0.10%
ALLIANCE OF ASSOCIATIONS OF ACCREDITED WORKERS IN THE WATER SECTOR ALLIANCE OF ASSOCIATIONS OF ACCREDITED WORKERS IN THE WATER SECTOR 317 0.09%
AKO AYOKO SA BAWAL NA DROGA AKO AYOKO SA BAWAL NA DROGA 316 0.09%
ANG TAGAPAGTAGUYOD NG SIKAP SA IKAUUNLAD NG MGA PINOY ANG TAGAPAGTAGUYOD NG SIKAP SA IKAUUNLAD NG MGA PINOY 314 0.09%
BABAE PARA SA KAUNLARAN BABAE PARA SA KAUNLARAN 302 0.09%
CHAMPIONS FOR INNOVATIVE EMPLOYMENT CHAMPIONS FOR INNOVATIVE EMPLOYMENT 301 0.09%
ADHIKAING TINATAGUYOD NG KOOPERATIBA ADHIKAING TINATAGUYOD NG KOOPERATIBA 292 0.08%
ABANTE BICOL ORAGON INC. ABANTE BICOL ORAGON INC. 290 0.08%
AHON PINOY AHON PINOY 285 0.08%
BAYANI BAYANI 285 0.08%
ANTI WAR / ANTI TERROR MINDANAO PEACE MOVEMENT ANTI WAR / ANTI TERROR MINDANAO PEACE MOVEMENT 284 0.08%
KABALIKAT NG MAMAMAYAN KABALIKAT NG MAMAMAYAN 282 0.08%
CONFEDERATION OF NON-STOCK SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATIONS, INC. CONFEDERATION OF NON-STOCK SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATIONS, INC. 276 0.08%
ATONG PAGLAUM ATONG PAGLAUM 272 0.08%
BAGONG HENERASYON BAGONG HENERASYON 264 0.08%
KAUNLARAN NG AGRIKULTURA, ASENSADONG PROBINSYA ANGAT NG BAYAN KAUNLARAN NG AGRIKULTURA, ASENSADONG PROBINSYA ANGAT NG BAYAN 255 0.07%
AABANTE EMMANUEL CIVIC ASSOCIATION AABANTE EMMANUEL CIVIC ASSOCIATION 252 0.07%
AGRI-AGRA NA REPORMA PARA SA MAGSASAKA NG PILIPINAS MOVEMENT AGRI-AGRA NA REPORMA PARA SA MAGSASAKA NG PILIPINAS MOVEMENT 227 0.07%
ADVOCATES FOR PENOLOGY ENHANCEMENT AND LEGAL ASSISTANCE ADVOCATES FOR PENOLOGY ENHANCEMENT AND LEGAL ASSISTANCE 226 0.07%
UGNAYAN NG NAGKAKAISANG LAYUNIN AT ADHIKAING DAKILA UGNAYAN NG NAGKAKAISANG LAYUNIN AT ADHIKAING DAKILA 216 0.06%
PARTIDO NG KATUTUBONG PILIPINO PARTIDO NG KATUTUBONG PILIPINO 214 0.06%
PARENTS ENABLING PARENTS COALITION PARTY PARENTS ENABLING PARENTS COALITION PARTY 205 0.06%
ANG TAO MUNA AT BAYAN ANG TAO MUNA AT BAYAN 190 0.05%
ALAY BUHAY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, INC. ALAY BUHAY COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATION, INC. 187 0.05%
LPG MARKETERS ASSOCIATION, INC. LPG MARKETERS ASSOCIATION, INC. 187 0.05%
ABANTE ILONGGO ABANTE ILONGGO 184 0.05%
ALLIANCE OF REGIONAL COALITIONS AGAINST PEOPLE'S POVERTY, INC. ALLIANCE OF REGIONAL COALITIONS AGAINST PEOPLE’S POVERTY, INC. 178 0.05%
ALAGAD PARTY-LIST ALAGAD PARTY-LIST 178 0.05%
1ST KABALIKAT NG BAYAN GINHAWANG SANGKATAUHAN 1ST KABALIKAT NG BAYAN GINHAWANG SANGKATAUHAN 177 0.05%
ALMA SA PAGKAHIKAOS AT IGNORANSIYA ALMA SA PAGKAHIKAOS AT IGNORANSIYA 175 0.05%
KAPATIRAN NG MGA NAKULONG NA WALANG SALA KAPATIRAN NG MGA NAKULONG NA WALANG SALA 175 0.05%
AGRICULTURAL SECTOR ALLIANCE OF THE PHILIPPINES, INC. AGRICULTURAL SECTOR ALLIANCE OF THE PHILIPPINES, INC. 174 0.05%
ADVOCATES FOR SPECIAL CHILDREN AND HANDICAPPED MOVEMENT ADVOCATES FOR SPECIAL CHILDREN AND HANDICAPPED MOVEMENT 172 0.05%
PRO-ACTIVE ON CLIMATE CHANGE LEADERS, INC. PRO-ACTIVE ON CLIMATE CHANGE LEADERS, INC. 162 0.05%
PARTIDO NG MANGGAGAWA PARTIDO NG MANGGAGAWA 161 0.05%
ACTION BROTHERHOOD FOR ACTIVE DREAMERS, INC. ACTION BROTHERHOOD FOR ACTIVE DREAMERS, INC. 157 0.05%
AKAP KAPATIRAN PARA SA TANGKILIKAN NG MGA OBRERO AKAP KAPATIRAN PARA SA TANGKILIKAN NG MGA OBRERO 156 0.05%
COCOFED-PHILIPPINE COCONUT PRODUCERS FEDERATION, INC. COCOFED-PHILIPPINE COCONUT PRODUCERS FEDERATION, INC. 153 0.04%
KALINGA-ADVOCACY FOR SOCIAL EMPOWERMENT AND NATION BUILDING THROUGH EASING POVERTY, INC. KALINGA-ADVOCACY FOR SOCIAL EMPOWERMENT AND NATION BUILDING THROUGH EASING POVERTY, INC. 144 0.04%
BUTIL FARMERS PARTY BUTIL FARMERS PARTY 137 0.04%
FIRST PEOPLE'S REPRESENTATIVE FOR INDIGENT STUDENT ATHLETES FIRST PEOPLE’S REPRESENTATIVE FOR INDIGENT STUDENT ATHLETES 133 0.04%
BATANG IWAS SA DROGA FOUNDATION, INC. BATANG IWAS SA DROGA FOUNDATION, INC. 121 0.03%
ALLIANCE FOR RURAL AND AGRARIAN RECONSTRUCTION, INC. ALLIANCE FOR RURAL AND AGRARIAN RECONSTRUCTION, INC. 119 0.03%
GREEN FORCE FOR THE ENVIRONMENT-SONS AND DAUGHTERS OF MOTHER EARTH GREEN FORCE FOR THE ENVIRONMENT-SONS AND DAUGHTERS OF MOTHER EARTH 116 0.03%
PAMILYANG OFW-SME NETWORK FOUNDATION PAMILYANG OFW-SME NETWORK FOUNDATION 111 0.03%
ANG AGRIKULTURA NATIN ISULONG ANG AGRIKULTURA NATIN ISULONG 110 0.03%
ANG KAPISANAN NG MGA SEAMAN ANG KAPISANAN NG MGA SEAMAN 108 0.03%
ABAKADA GURO ABAKADA GURO 107 0.03%
AKO AGILA SA NAGKAISANG MAGSASAKA AKO AGILA SA NAGKAISANG MAGSASAKA 107 0.03%
KASANGGA SA KAUNLARAN, INC. KASANGGA SA KAUNLARAN, INC. 106 0.03%
ALLIANCE FOR COMMUNITY TRANSFORMATION AND SERVICE ALLIANCE FOR COMMUNITY TRANSFORMATION AND SERVICE 104 0.03%
ASOSASYON NG MGA MALILIIT NA NEGOSYANTENG GUMAGANAP ASOSASYON NG MGA MALILIIT NA NEGOSYANTENG GUMAGANAP 98 0.03%
ADHIKAING ALAY NG MARINO SA SAMBAYANAN, INC. ADHIKAING ALAY NG MARINO SA SAMBAYANAN, INC. 97 0.03%
AN WARAY AN WARAY 96 0.03%
ADHIKAIN AT KILUSAN NG ORDINARYONG TAO PARA SA LUPA, HANAPBUHAY AT KAUNLARAN ADHIKAIN AT KILUSAN NG ORDINARYONG TAO PARA SA LUPA, HANAPBUHAY AT KAUNLARAN 95 0.03%
ARTS BUSINESS AND SCIENCE PROFESSIONALS ARTS BUSINESS AND SCIENCE PROFESSIONALS 94 0.03%
UNITED MOVEMENT AGAINST DRUGS FOUNDATION, INC. UNITED MOVEMENT AGAINST DRUGS FOUNDATION, INC. 92 0.03%
KOALISYON NG KATUTUBONG SAMAHAN NG PILIPINAS KOALISYON NG KATUTUBONG SAMAHAN NG PILIPINAS 91 0.03%
UNITED CADDIES AND GREEN KEEPERS ASSOCIATION OF THE PHILIPPINES UNITED CADDIES AND GREEN KEEPERS ASSOCIATION OF THE PHILIPPINES 91 0.03%
ONE NATION EMPOWERED BY TECHNOLOGY ONE NATION EMPOWERED BY TECHNOLOGY 86 0.02%
ALYANSA LUMAD MINDANAO, INC. ALYANSA LUMAD MINDANAO, INC. 85 0.02%
ABANG LINGKOD, INC. ABANG LINGKOD, INC. 83 0.02%
AKBAY KALUSUGAN, INC. AKBAY KALUSUGAN, INC. 80 0.02%
ANGKAN KATUTUBO, INC. ANGKAN KATUTUBO, INC. 76 0.02%
ASSOCIATION OF ADMINISTRATORS, PROFESSIONALS AND SENIORS ASSOCIATION OF ADMINISTRATORS, PROFESSIONALS AND SENIORS 74 0.02%
BAGONG KOALISYON NG NAGKAKAISANG SAMAHAN SA SEKTOR NG TRANSPORTASYON BAGONG KOALISYON NG NAGKAKAISANG SAMAHAN SA SEKTOR NG TRANSPORTASYON 73 0.02%
DAMAYAN ALLIANCE OF THE AGING and DISABLED FILIPINOS, INC. DAMAYAN ALLIANCE OF THE AGING and DISABLED FILIPINOS, INC. 73 0.02%
ALLIANCE OF MINDANAO ELDERS ALLIANCE OF MINDANAO ELDERS 70 0.02%
ALYANSA NG MGA NAULILA NG MGA TAGAPAGTANGGOL NG BAYAN ALYANSA NG MGA NAULILA NG MGA TAGAPAGTANGGOL NG BAYAN 69 0.02%
ALAGAAN NATIN ATING KALUSUGAN ALAGAAN NATIN ATING KALUSUGAN 65 0.02%
ALLIANCE OF BELIEVERS BRIDGE IN ATTAINING ACCURATE AND MEANINGFUL ADVANCEMENT ALLIANCE OF BELIEVERS BRIDGE IN ATTAINING ACCURATE AND MEANINGFUL ADVANCEMENT 63 0.02%
SAGIP KAPWA FOUNDATION, INC. SAGIP KAPWA FOUNDATION, INC. 62 0.02%
ABONO ABONO 62 0.02%
ALYANSA NG MEDIA AT SHOWBIZ ALYANSA NG MEDIA AT SHOWBIZ 58 0.02%
BAGO NATIONAL CULTURAL SOCIETY OF THE PHILIPPINES BAGO NATIONAL CULTURAL SOCIETY OF THE PHILIPPINES 58 0.02%
SOCIAL MOVEMENT FOR ACTIVE REFORM AND TRANSPARENCY SOCIAL MOVEMENT FOR ACTIVE REFORM AND TRANSPARENCY 55 0.02%
SULONG! BARANGAY MOVEMENT SULONG! BARANGAY MOVEMENT 55 0.02%
ALLIANCE AND ADVOCATES FOR SENIOR CITIZENS' AFFAIRS ALLIANCE AND ADVOCATES FOR SENIOR CITIZENS’ AFFAIRS 53 0.02%
ALLIANCE OF VOLUNTEER EDUCATORS ALLIANCE OF VOLUNTEER EDUCATORS 51 0.01%
ALAY SA BAYAN NG MALAYANG PROPESYONAL AT REPORMANG KALAKAL ALAY SA BAYAN NG MALAYANG PROPESYONAL AT REPORMANG KALAKAL 49 0.01%
ABOT TANAW ABOT TANAW 47 0.01%
ALLIANCE OF VIGILANT PROTECTORS OF AQUATIC PRODUCTS ALLIANCE OF VIGILANT PROTECTORS OF AQUATIC PRODUCTS 47 0.01%
CITIZEN POWER MOVEMENT, INC. CITIZEN POWER MOVEMENT, INC. 46 0.01%
BINHI: PARTIDO NG MGA MAGSASAKA PARA SA MGA MAGSASAKA BINHI: PARTIDO NG MGA MAGSASAKA PARA SA MGA MAGSASAKA 42 0.01%
ORGANIZATION OF REGIONAL ADVOCATES FOR GOOD GOVERNANCE ONWARD NATION-BUILDING ORGANIZATION OF REGIONAL ADVOCATES FOR GOOD GOVERNANCE ONWARD NATION-BUILDING 40 0.01%
ALAY SERBISYO (WORKERS IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR ECONOMY) ALAY SERBISYO (WORKERS IN THE INFORMAL SECTOR ECONOMY) 37 0.01%
KABUKLURAN NG MGA KABABAIHANG FILIPINA SA TIMOG KATAGALUGAN KABUKLURAN NG MGA KABABAIHANG FILIPINA SA TIMOG KATAGALUGAN 35 0.01%
ALLIANCE OF NATIONALISTIC AND GENUINE PROGRAM FOR AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT TOWARDS ECONOMIC REFORM ALLIANCE OF NATIONALISTIC AND GENUINE PROGRAM FOR AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT TOWARDS ECONOMIC REFORM 32 0.01%
PEOPLES FREEDOM PARTY PEOPLES FREEDOM PARTY 28 0.01%
KABABAIHANG LINGKOD BAYAN SA PILIPINAS KABABAIHANG LINGKOD BAYAN SA PILIPINAS 28 0.01%
NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR COMMUTERS PROTECTION NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR COMMUTERS PROTECTION 26 0.01%
SECTORAL PARTY OF ANG MINERO (ANG MINERO) SECTORAL PARTY OF ANG MINERO (ANG MINERO) 24 0.01%
ALLIANCE TRANSPORT SECTOR ALLIANCE TRANSPORT SECTOR 21 0.01%
SMALL FARMERS AND LAND TILLERS ASSOCIATION OF THE PHILIPPINES SMALL FARMERS AND LAND TILLERS ASSOCIATION OF THE PHILIPPINES 21 0.01%
BINIGKIS NA INTERES NG MGA DRAYBER SA ADHIKAIN, INC. BINIGKIS NA INTERES NG MGA DRAYBER SA ADHIKAIN, INC. 19 0.01%
ALLIANCE OF BICOLNON PARTY ALLIANCE OF BICOLNON PARTY 16 0.00%
ANG SAMAHAN PARA SA MAGANDANG KABUHAYAN ANG SAMAHAN PARA SA MAGANDANG KABUHAYAN 14 0.00%
ANG GALING PINOY ANG GALING PINOY 13 0.00%
BIGKIS PINOY MOVEMENT BIGKIS PINOY MOVEMENT 13 0.00%
UNITED FILIPINO SEAFARERS UNITED FILIPINO SEAFARERS 11 0.00%
YOUTH LEAGUE FOR PEACE AND ADVANCEMENT YOUTH LEAGUE FOR PEACE AND ADVANCEMENT 11 0.00%
ANG NATIONAL COALITION ON INDIGENOUS PEOPLE'S ACTION ANG NATIONAL COALITION ON INDIGENOUS PEOPLE’S ACTION 9 0.00%
PASANG MASDA NATIONWIDE, INC. PASANG MASDA NATIONWIDE, INC. 8 0.00%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 439520

Election Result for 2nd Legdist of Maguindanao

MEMBER, HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES of MAGUINDANAO – SECOND LEGDIST

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
DATUMANONG, Simeon A. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 123111 100.00%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 200089
MEMBER, HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES of MAGUINDANAO – FIRST LEGDIST

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
SEMA, Bai Sandra A. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 143546 65.98%
DILANGALEN, Didagen P. INDEPENDENT 74005 34.02%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 232149
PROVINCIAL GOVERNOR of MAGUINDANAO

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
MANGUDADATU, Esmael G. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 153706 42.31%
SINSUAT, Datu Ombra Q. BAGUMBAYAN-VNP 141001 38.81%
MIDTIMBANG, Midpantao M. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 68586 18.88%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 384106
PROVINCIAL VICE-GOVERNOR of MAGUINDANAO

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
MASTURA, Ismael V. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 173471 51.43%
AMPATUAN, Andal Sr S. INDEPENDENT 142783 42.33%
CANDAO, Ma-Arouph B. ISLAMIC PARTY OF THE PHILIPPINES 17208 5.10%
ABUTAZIL, Shaydee A. INDEPENDENT 3824 1.13%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 384106
MEMBER, SANGGUNIANG PANLALAWIGAN of MAGUINDANAO – SECOND PROVDIST

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
PAGLAS , Ibrahim Iv P. INDEPENDENT 70909 12.57%
AMPATUAN, Datu Sarip K. INDEPENDENT 65831 11.67%
AMPATUAN, Sajid Islam U. INDEPENDENT 65371 11.59%
AMPATUAN, Puti M. INDEPENDENT 60180 10.67%
MIDTIMBANG, Michael E. INDEPENDENT 50817 9.01%
UTTO, Malumpil M. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 41535 7.36%
MATALAM, Jaafar Apollo M L. BAGUMBAYAN-VNP 40574 7.19%
PAGLALA, Montano M. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 36561 6.48%
MONTAWAL, Usop E. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 35641 6.32%
MAMALINTA, Mando Sr B. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 32905 5.83%
KASIM, Edres U. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 22820 4.04%
MANALASAL, Abdulmanan S. INDEPENDENT 17496 3.10%
ADZIS, Datuwata U. INDEPENDENT 14718 2.61%
CAMSA, Vicente Salde A. INDEPENDENT 5035 0.89%
NALAB, Abonawas K. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 3791 0.67%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 200089
MEMBER, SANGGUNIANG PANLALAWIGAN of MAGUINDANAO – FIRST PROVDIST

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
ABO , Talib Jr M. INDEPENDENT 90179 14.46%
SINSUAT, Russman Q. BAGUMBAYAN-VNP 83435 13.38%
LIMBONA, Asnawi S. INDEPENDENT 79761 12.79%
IMAM, Nashrullah A. BAGUMBAYAN-VNP 78256 12.55%
DAGALANGIT, Bocari M. AKSYON DEMOKRATIKO 60334 9.68%
TOMAWIS, Raul S. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 55909 8.97%
MAIK, Saqqaf S. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 54767 8.78%
BANGON, Rosalim T. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 28988 4.65%
SINSUAT, Michael I C. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 28412 4.56%
CANDAO, Abdulbayan S. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 27014 4.33%
ABAS, Mastura M. NATIONALIST PEOPLES COALITION 18040 2.89%
LIDASAN, Armando D. INDEPENDENT 7384 1.18%
KASIM, Muslimin S. INDEPENDENT 3832 0.61%
DAUDIE, Alonto B. INDEPENDENT 3571 0.57%
KASAN, Ebrahim S. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 2539 0.41%
DINGGO, Kamad T. INDEPENDENT 1111 0.18%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 191299
 

· · · · ·
Copyright © 2000-2010 Smartmatic Corporation. All rights reserved.

Election Result for Maguindanao – Senator

SENATOR of PHILIPPINES

Candidate Party Votes Percentage
BONG REVILLA, Ramon, Jr. B. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 189915 8.84%
TAMANO, Adel A. NACIONALISTA PARTY 130748 6.08%
DEFENSOR SANTIAGO, Miriam P. PEOPLES REFORM PARTY 118504 5.51%
ENRILE, Juan Ponce -. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 99638 4.64%
ESTRADA, Jinggoy E. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 99328 4.62%
LAPID, Manuel M. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 97399 4.53%
MARCOS, Ferdinand, Jr. R. NACIONALISTA PARTY 92157 4.29%
CAYETANO, Pilar Juliana S. NACIONALISTA PARTY 78662 3.66%
OSMEÑA, Sergio III D. INDEPENDENT 70273 3.27%
LAO, Yasmin B. LIBERAL PARTY 69691 3.24%
DRILON, Franklin M. LIBERAL PARTY 67127 3.12%
RECTO, Ralph G. LIBERAL PARTY 60706 2.82%
HONTIVEROS-BARAQUEL, Ana LIBERAL PARTY 56030 2.61%
PIMENTEL, Gwendolyn D. PARTIDO DEMOKRATIKO PILIPINO LAKAS NG BAYAN 52531 2.44%
GUINGONA , Teofisto III D. LIBERAL PARTY 51608 2.40%
DE VENECIA, Jose III P. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 50257 2.34%
SOTTO , Vicente III C. NATIONALIST PEOPLES COALITION 50229 2.34%
BIAZON, Rozzano Rufino B. LIBERAL PARTY 48131 2.24%
LIM, Danilo D. INDEPENDENT 44172 2.05%
ALONTO, Zafrullah M. BANGON PILIPINAS 43618 2.03%
REMULLA, Gilbert Cesar C. NACIONALISTA PARTY 43111 2.01%
QUERUBIN, Ariel O. NACIONALISTA PARTY 41365 1.92%
ALBANI, Shariff Ibrahim H. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 36318 1.69%
ROCO, Sonia M. LIBERAL PARTY 35239 1.64%
PLAZA, Rodolfo G. NATIONALIST PEOPLES COALITION 32890 1.53%
ACOSTA, Jr. Nereus O. LIBERAL PARTY 32204 1.50%
BELLO, Silvestre III H. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 32083 1.49%
LACSON, Alexander L. LIBERAL PARTY 27565 1.28%
OSMEÑA, Emilio Mario R. ABAG PROMDI 24443 1.14%
MAZA, Liza L. INDEPENDENT 23738 1.10%
OCAMPO, Saturnino C. BAYAN MUNA 21449 1.00%
GUICO, Ramon, Jr. N. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 17873 0.83%
LOZADA, Jose Apolinario Jr L. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 16239 0.76%
MITRA, Ramon B. NACIONALISTA PARTY 14720 0.68%
LANGIT, Rey M. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 14399 0.67%
TATAD, Francisco S. GABAYBAYAN/GAD 14036 0.65%
PAPIN, Imelda A. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 12119 0.56%
TAMAYO, Reginald B. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 11919 0.55%
BAUTISTA, J.V. L. PWERSA NG MASANG PILIPINO 11671 0.54%
BAUTISTA, Martin D. LIBERAL PARTY 9752 0.45%
OPLE, Susan V. NACIONALISTA PARTY 9629 0.45%
VILLANUEVA, Hector L. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 9515 0.44%
LAMBINO, Raul L. LAKAS KABALIKAT NG MALAYANG PILIPINO CHRISTIAN MUSLIM DEMOCRATS 8683 0.40%
OCAMPO, Ramoncito P. BANGON PILIPINAS 7900 0.37%
DAVID, Rizalito Y. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 7646 0.36%
ESPINOSA, Nanette M. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 7391 0.34%
PALPARAN, Jovito Jr S. INDEPENDENT 5702 0.27%
MAAMBONG, Regalado E. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 5482 0.26%
IMBONG, Jo Aurea M. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 5306 0.25%
VIRGINES, Israel N. BANGON PILIPINAS 4658 0.22%
TINSAY, Alexander B. BANGON PILIPINAS 4267 0.20%
CAUNAN, Henry B. PARTIDO DEMOKRATIKO PILIPINO LAKAS NG BAYAN 3955 0.18%
INOCENCIO, Ma. Katherine L. R. BANGON PILIPINAS 3941 0.18%
SISON, Adrian O. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 3496 0.16%
PAREDES, Zosimo Jesus II M. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 3193 0.15%
PRINCESA, Reynaldo R. INDEPENDENT 3059 0.14%
NIKABULIN, Adz G. BANGON PILIPINAS 3055 0.14%
VALDEHUESA, Manuel Jr E. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 2627 0.12%
TARRAZONA, Hector M. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 2347 0.11%
LOOD, Alma A. KILUSANG BAGONG LIPUNAN 2205 0.10%
RIÑOZA-PLAZO, Maria Gracia D. ANG KAPATIRAN PARTY 1630 0.08%
Statistics
Total number of Voters who actually voted 439520

Published by: www.electionresults.comelec.gov.ph

Maguindanao 2008 COA Audit 6

. Value for Money Audit:

       A Value for Money Audit was conducted on the Twenty Percent (20%) Economic Development Fund of the Province Of Maguindanao for the year ended December 31, 2008, pursuant to COA Resolution No. 2006-002, dated 31, January 2006; Re-Conduct of Comprehensive Audits by the Offices of the Commission, and in accordance with the audit thrust of the local government unit.

       Pursuant to the said COA Resolution, Auditors shall conduct a compliance as well as Performance or Value for Money (VFM) audits, complementary to their financial audit under the RBAA.

       Among others, the objectives of the Value for Money (VFM) Audit is to determine whether infrastructure projects funded through the 20% Development fund are clearly defined and implemented in accordance with the goals and objectives of the LGU and in compliance with existing guidelines of regulatory bodies; to ascertain whether the projects were implemented as planned and in accordance with the performance criteria/ standards set by the LGU; and to determine whether the construction of new and rehabilitation of existing roads and bridges resulted to easy transport of products, lesser transportation cost, accessibility of people going to and from places, reduced travel time and eventually resulted to better/improved living and economic condition of the people.

Finding:

A. Favorable Observation

Based on the accomplishment report submitted as of December 31, 2008,the Province of Maguindanao were able to complete 100% the 38 items of different projects funded from the twenty percent (20%) Economic Development Fund.

Pursuant to the Joint Memorandum Circular No. 1 of the DILG &  DBM, dated September 20, 2005, which reads in part:

General Policies:
2.1 In accordance with Section 287 of the Local Government Code, every LGU shall appropriate in its annual budget no less than twenty percent (20%) of its annual internal revenue allotment for development projects.

2.3 All projects to be funded shall:
       2.3.1 Contribute to the attainment of desirable socio-economic development and environmental management outcomes;

3.0 Projects Covered
       3.2 Economic Development

       3.2.3 Construction/rehabilitation of farm to market roads
       3.2.4 Construction/rehabilitation of local roads or bridges
       A review made  on the Annual Performance Budget for CY 2008 of the Province of Maguindanao, an amount of P 90,254,222.40, which is computed at 20% of the estimated Internal Revenue Allotment (IRA) of P90,254,222.40 were appropriated for funding the Priority Development projects of the LGU (See Annex P).

       Out of this amount, and based on the accomplishment reports submitted as of December 31, 2008, the Provincial Government of Maguindanao had completed 100% all the 38 items of different projects, comprising rehabilitation of various provincial and barangay roads, in accordance with the program of works, at a total cost of P104,240,837.16, or exceeding the estimate of P90,254,222.40 by P13,986,614.76 (See Annexes R1-R2). These projects were implemented by administration as approved by various Sanggunian Panlalawigan Resolutions of the Provincial Government of Maguindanao.

       However, due to the existing armed conflict in most of the municipalities in the Province of Maguindanao and due to limited manpower and time constraints, we were only able to conduct an ocular inspections only on the following selected projects, such as:

       1. Rehabilitation of Bagong Farm to Market Road (FMR), Shariff Aguak, Maguindanao, costing P2,721,027.98;

       2. Rehabilitation of Bagong – Timabangan Farm to Market Road , Shariff Aguak, Maguindanao, costing P 2,333,119.38;
      
       3. Rehabilitation of Barangay Road – Mamasapano, Maguindanao, costing P3,462,072.12;
      
       4. Rehabilitation of Matagabong Farm to Market Road, Ampatuan, Maguindanao, costing P 1,1958,282.06;
      
       5. Rehabilitation of Maganoy – Lebak Provincial Road, Shariff Aguak, Maguindanao, costing P2,672,181.24;
      
       6. Rehabilitation of Meta – Talibarok Road, Shariff Aguak, Maguindanao, costing P2,554,290.68;
      
       7. Rehabilitation of Mapayag – Talitay Provincial Road, Datu Anggal Midtimbang, Maguindanao, costing P 5,827,503.02; and
      
       8. Rehabilitation of Timbangan – Tapekan Road, Shariff Aguak, Maguindanao, costing, P2,338,119.38.
      
       
       During the ocular inspection made on the said projects, we have observed that the roads are well maintained and passable to any type of motor vehicles which transport passengers and farm products such as corn, banana, palay, copra and similar other products from the farm to the markets in Shariff Aguak and neighboring municipalities. It also contributes to the reduced travel time for commuters and accordingly, helps improve the living condition of the people, especially farmers residing in the locality, because of the much higher cost of farm products sold in the markets than when bought in the farm by buyers and middlemen.
B.
Findings and Recommendations:
 
Finding:

1. Due to the non submission of the Calendar Year (CY) 2008 Annual Investment Plan of the Auditee by the Provincial Planning Development Office, we were not able to ascertain the relevance and necessity of the projects in terms of the overall Annual Investment Plan and on the priorities and needs of the constituents through the Local Development Council.

Pursuant to the Joint Memorandum Circular No. 1 of the DILG & DBM, dated September 20, 2005, which reads in part:

General Policies

2.2 The twenty percent (20%)  economic development fund shall be utilized to finance the priority projects, as embodied in the duly approved local development plan that directly support the Medium-Term Philippine Development Plan and the Medium-Term Public Investment Program.

       One objective of the Value for Money Audit is to ascertain the relevance and necessity of the projects in terms of the overall Annual Investment Plan and on the priorities and needs of the constituents through the Local Development Council. The Annual Investment Plan will serve as one of the criteria in determining whether the infrastructure projects implemented by the Auditee were the one approved by the LGU for implementation for the  year and whether the approved projects are among the identified priorities of the LGU based on the objective set.

       In this regard, the Office of the Audit Team Leader, Provincial Accounts, had sent  communications to the Provincial Planning Development Office  for the submission of the Annual Investment Plan of the agency for CY 2008 and other reports, dated January 12, 2009, (See Annex I). This is in line with the Value for Money (VFM) Audit on twenty percent (20%) economic development fund for CY 2008 on all provinces and cities nationwide, as one of the audit thrust of the local government sector of the Commission on Audit.
       
        However, our communication letters were not officially responded to by the office concerned. According to the PPDO, their office were still in the process of completing the Annual Investment Plan for CY 2008. Thus, we were not able to ascertain the relevance and necessity of the projects in terms of the  AIP and on the priorities and needs of the constituents through the Local Development Council.
      
      
       They assured us however, that as soon as it is completed, though already delayed, copies of which will be provided to our office.
      
       This is a reiteration of the prior year finding which were not complied to by management.
      
Recommendation forTawi-tawi Government:

 The Provincial Planning Development Office should prepare the Annual Investment Plan (AIP) of the Auditee on time, in order to ascertain the relevance and necessity of the projects in terms of the AIP and on the priorities and needs of the constituents through the Local Development Council, and whether the approved projects were among the identified priorities of the LGU based on the objectives set. Copy of the AIP should be furnished the Office of the Auditor, for our reference and guidance in the conduct of the VFM audit, and for rendering appropriate management advisory services on time.

Maguindanao 2008 COA Audit 5

5. Supplies and materials procured by the auditee totaling to P4,532,553.00 were charged outright to an Office Supplies Expenses account, instead of recording it to an inventory account, in violation to the New Government Accounting System (NGAS). 

 One of the basic feature of the New Government Accounting System (NGAS) is the use of the perpetual inventory of supplies and materials, which reads:

 “Supplies and materials purchased for inventory purpose shall be recorded using the perpetual inventory system. Regular purchases shall be coursed through the inventory account and issuances thereof shall be recorded as they take place except those purchased out of petty cash fund which shall be for immediate use and not for stock. Such case shall be charged immediately to the appropriate expense account.”
       Based on the analysis of the financial statements submitted by  the accounting office as of the end of the year, a total amount of office supplies and materials procured by the auditee and charged outright to an office supplies expense account totaled to P 4,532,553.00, breakdown of which are as follows:

General                         Trust
Fund            SEF        Fund           Total

Office Supplies            P4,532,553.00        0.00        0.00         P4,532,553.00

       An analysis made on the trial balances on general fund during the whole year showed the following balances on the Inventory account:

Office Supplies Inventory:

Dr. Balance                      Credit Balance

2008
Jan. to May                  P     2,825.00                         P0.00
June to Nov.                   152,825.00                            0.00
Dec.                                  44,105.00

       As can be gleaned on the extracts of the balances of the general ledger account, there was no credit balances on the Office Supplies Inventory Account. Had the accounting office actually used the Perpetual Inventory Method, all supplies and materials acquisitions by the auditee should had been a debit to Office Supplies Inventory and issuances of supplies and materials should reflect a credit to Office Supplies Inventory.

       However, that is not the case as reflected in the general ledger for Office Supplies Inventory, which lead us to conclude that  the auditee does not actually make use of the perpetual inventory method as required under NGAS.
      
       Verification of stock cards on office supplies showed that the account is not properly maintained and updated, as not all acquisitions and issuances of office supplies were not regularly monitored and recorded. The stock card shall be properly maintained at the supply and property unit for each item in stock and physical inventory of supplies shall be reconciled quarterly with the stock card and any discrepancies shall be immediately verified and adjusted.
      
       Dialogue made with the Provincial Accountant disclosed that the use of the expense account on supplies and materials acquisitions were due to the fact that there was no actual stockroom to deposit the stocks and the usual procedure is to deliver most of the stocks to the requisitioning office, hence the difficulty in assessing the actual inventory on hand at the end of each month.
      
Recommendation for Tawi-tawi Government:
      
       The Provincial Accountant should record the supplies and materials acquisitions of the auditee using the perpetual Inventory Method as required under the New Government Accounting System (NGAS). This is done by debiting the Office Supplies Inventory Account for all receipts of supplies and materials. Any issuances of supplies and materials should be made thru a report to be submitted on a monthly basis to the accounting office by the supplies and materials unit of the Provincial General Service Office. In which case the entry should be a debit to Office Supplies Expense and a credit to Office Supplies Inventory.

Maguindanao 2008 COA Audit 4

4. An outstanding payables due to different government agencies such as BIR, GSIS, PAG-IBIG and PHILHEALTH totaling to P 7,088,625.70 remained unsettled as at year-end, in violation to Section 6 (a) of PD 1146.

       Pursuant to Section 6 (a) of PD 1146, compulsory deductions made from the monthly salaries of employees such as GSIS, Pag-ibig and Medicare premiums and contributions and the like should be remitted to the agencies concerned within the first ten (10) days of each calendar month following the month to which the contribution applies.
      
       Based on the review made on the year end Balance Sheet submitted by the Provincial Accountant, the auditee had an unsettled payables to different government agencies such as:
      
       Due to BIR                                                              P 3,244,089.13
       Due to GSIS                                                               1,307,278.17
       Due to PAG-IBIG                                                      1,169,071.14
       Due to PHILHEALTH                                               1,368,187.26
                                                     —————–
            Total                                                                    P7,088,625.70
==========
      
       Revenue regulations require that taxes withheld from contractors and suppliers shall be remitted to the Bureau of Internal Revenue (BIR) within ten (10) days following the close of the calendar months during which the withholding was made.
      
       Further, accounting and auditing rules and regulations requires that GSIS, PAG-IBIG and PHILHEALTH  premiums, contributions, loan repayments and similar other obligations should be zeroed out or fully settled by every governments units concerned at every end of the year, as these obligations were covered by appropriate budget and availability of funds. Besides,  delayed or non payment of monthly premiums, contributions and loan repayments to said government agencies by the auditee may result to the delay, if non availment of  benefits and privileges due to the employees such as retirement benefits, salary loans, policy loans and similar other benefits.
      
       The Provincial Accountant reasoned out that some of these unremitted obligations due to different government agencies mentioned were obligations of the past administration/s and current appropriations were not enough to cover said obligations. However, accordingly, representations were made to increase budget in the ensuing  year to cover the unpaid remittances of previous administration/s.
      
Recommendation for Tawi-tawi Government:
      
       The Provincial Accountant and the Provincial Treasurer should remit promptly the taxes withheld from the employees and supplier/s to the BIR and monthly premiums, contributions and loan repayments to the GSIS, PAG-IBIG, and PHILHEALTH in the total amount of P7,088,625.70, as prescribed under BIR regulations and Section 6 (a) of PD 1146, so that the employees can avail regularly on the benefits and privileges offered by the said government agencies. Supplemental budget to cover said unpaid obligations, whenever allowable under existing laws, rules and regulations, can likewise be an option.

Manguindanao 2008 COA Audit 3

3. The accuracy, validity and existence of the Property, Plant and Equipment valued in the Balance Sheets at a total amount of P 345,227,725.51 cannot be ascertained, due to the absence of Unit Value for all items in the submitted Year End Inventory Report by the Provincial General Services Office.

   The Manual on The New Government Accounting System (NGAS) provides:

       “The Physical count of property, plant and equipment by type shall be made annually and reported on the Report of Physical Count of Property, Plant and Equipment (RPCPPE)”.

       The RPCPPE shall be accomplished as follows:

> Type of Property, Plant and Equipment (PPE) – Property, plant and equipment account name such as Heavy Equipment, Technical and Scientific Equipment, Motor Vehicle, Office Equipment, Furniture and Fixtures, etc.
> Date – date as of a given date
> Name of Accountable Officer
> Official Designation
> Agency/Office – branch or office where accountable officer is assigned
> Date of Assumption – first day of assumption of the duties and responsibilities as accountable officer.
> Article – type or item or article e.g. personal computer, printer, filing cabinet, etc.
> Description – brief description of the article/item e.g. acer, monitor for personal computer, Epson for printer, etc.
> Property Number – assigned property number by the Supply and Property Unit.
> Unit of Measure – e.g. piece, set, etc.
> Unit Value – cost per quantity unit
> Balance per Card – quantity of items or articles appearing in the Property, Plant and Equipment Ledger Card.
> On Hand per Count – quantity of items or articles per physical count.
> Shortage/Overage – excess of the quantity and total value of items or articles per Property, Plant and Equipment Ledger Card over that of the physical count or vice versa.
> Remarks – whereabouts, conditions and other relevant information relative to property, plant and equipment.

   The Balance Sheets submitted by the Accounting Office as at Year End contained the following information on Property, Plant and Equipment:

Book Value
——————-
General Fund                                       P 330,335,489.71
SEF                                                             1,408,885.09
Trust Fund                                                 13,483,350.71
———————
Total (See Annex I)                        P 345,227,725.51
============
       However, a review made on the December 31, 2008 Inventory Report on Property Plant and Equipment submitted by the Office of the Provincial General Services for verification and reconciliation purposes, showed that, said report were wanting in information such as the Unit Value or cost per quantity unit of fixed assets, Balance per Card, On Hand per Count, and Shortage/Overage both for quantity and value (See Annexes N1-N4 & O1-O2). Apparently, reconciliation of the total cost of Property, Plant and Equipment (PPE) with the Inventory Report  is not possible.
      
       Verification of the property ledger cards maintained at the Provincial General Services Office disclosed that said record was not properly maintained and updated, thus, alternative audit procedures performed to ascertain the validity, existence and correctness of the PPE as presented in the Balance Sheets at a total amount of P 345,227,725.51 cannot be made. It is possible that there are some fixed assets which were either acquired by the Auditee but not recorded in the respective ledger cards or already missing or non existing but still on records.
      
       It is likewise an indication that no reconciliation of property ledger cards maintained at the Provincial General Services Office and the property, plant and equipment ledger cards at the Office of the Provincial Accountant were not performed regularly.
      
       This is similar to the prior year audit finding, although the amount of Property, Plant and Equipment differs than that of last year.
      
Recommendation for Tawi-tawi Government:

       The Office of the Provincial General Services should update all the individual property ledger cards for all items acquired or disposed of by the Agency during the year. The information contained in the Report on Physical Count of Property Plant and Equipment (RPCPPE) should be properly filled up as prescribed under the NGAS. Any discrepancies between the physical count and the property cards should be reconciled and verified and adjustments shall be made on the latter. The original copy of the physical inventory report shall be submitted to the accounting office to effect any adjustments in the property, plant and equipment ledger cards and the general ledgers for any discrepancies and for the computation of depreciations, in case of acquisition or disposal.

Maguindanao 2008 COA Audit 2

2. The validity, existence and correctness of the Cash in Bank – LCCA amounting to P107,268,451.94 cannot be ascertained, due to the inability of the Office of  the Provincial Accountant to prepare the Bank Reconciliation Statement for the whole year, in violation to COA Circular No 96-011.

       COA Circular No. 96-011 dated October 2, 1996 which modifies Provincial Circular No. 19, dated June 15, 1970 delineates the responsibility for the preparation of the bank reconciliation statements to the Chief of the Accounting Department instead of the Provincial Treasurer.

       Under the said Circular, the local accountant shall within ten (10) days from the receipts of the Bank Statements, reconcile the same (BS) with the General Ledger (GL) and prepare the BRS in five (5) copies distributed as follows: Original – Bank Manager; Duplicate – Provincial Auditor; Triplicate – Provincial Treasurer; Quadruplicate – COA Regional Director and Quintuplicate – Provincial Accountant.

       The Accountant shall draw journal vouchers to record all valid reconciling items that require adjustments and corrections in the GL. The duplicate and quadruplicate copies of the BRS including the paid checks, original copies of debit/credit memos shall be submitted within ten (10) days from receipt after the end of each month. The Auditor shall verify the duly certified BRS and supporting schedules within ten (10) days from receipt of the same. The Auditor shall after verification, affix his signature on the BRS under the notation “VERIFIED AND FOUND CORRECT” and furnish the COA Directors concerned the duly verified BRS on a monthly basis or when there is an urgent need for the same.

       The Province of Maguindanao maintains deposits for the General Fund, Trust Fund, Twenty Percent (20%) Economic Development Fund and Special Education Fund at the Philippine National Bank, Cotabato City Branch.

       Based on the Balance Sheets submitted by the Office of the Provincial Accountant as at December 31, 2008, the Cash in Bank-Local Currency Account had the following balances:

Amount
——————
General Fund                                                         P    3,135,562.79
SEF                                                                                 463,441.02
Trust Fund                                                               103,669,448.13
——————–
    Total                                                                  P107,268,451.94
============

       However, the validity and existence of said account cannot be ascertained due to the inability of the Office of the Provincial Accountant to prepare and submit the Bank Reconciliation Statements during the twelve (12) months period for all funds.

       Analysis made showed that the balances of the account on all funds were derived from the unadjusted balance of the general ledgers and no adjustments were made to reconcile the amount with the bank balances arising out of checks issued during the year and were not presented in the bank for payment, as well as debit memos, such as loan amortizations and bank charges. Items such as credit memos, and other relevant adjustments in the books were not also made. Had the Provincial Accountant prepared the Bank Reconciliation Statements on a regular basis, the discrepancies in recording reconciling items could have been avoided, and a more realistic balances of the Cash – LCCA could have been presented as at year end.

       The recurring justification offered by the Provincial Accountant was the difficulty in determining the beginning balances per books and outstanding checks and other reconciling items of the previous period/s, due to the failure, accordingly, of the previous accountant/s a few years back in regularly preparing the BRS for all funds.

       Consequently, the Cash in Bank – Local Currency, Current Account reflected in the consolidated Balance Sheets for CY 2008 totaling to P 3,599,003.81, may either be overstated or understated due o the non preparation by the Office of the Provincial Accountant as at year end in support of the account.

       This finding is similar to that of the prior year. However, the current year amount is more material and significant than that of last year.

Recommendation forTawi-tawi Government:

       The Provincial Accountant should painstakingly prepare the monthly Bank Reconciliation Statements on all funds, pursuant to COA Circular No. 96-011 dated October 2, 1996, in order to render validity and reliability on the Cash in Bank, Local Currency, Current Accounts totaling to P107,268,451.94, and submit the BRS to the Office of the Auditor within the prescribed period, for review and verification.

Next Page»